Note to self: make sure to put that "non disclosure" sig on the bottom of my emails!

(Denver WestWord) The focus of this dust-up is “Allen St. Pierre on Medical Marijuana,” published by Steve Bloom’s Celebstoner.com website on January 5. The piece, on view in its entirety below, begins with a bold statement: “Defending the ‘medical’ cannabis industry is so yesterday. Why not acknowledge the political and legal farce it is and focus on the real problem at hand: ending cannabis prohibition?” From there, St. Pierre describes medical marijuana as a “sham” on par with prescription alcohol during the 1920s liquor-prohibition era, accuses the MMJ industry of opposing broader legalization efforts like California’s Proposition 19, and maintains that cannabis consumers should be able to get “good, affordable cannabis products without having to go through the insult and expense of ‘qualifying’ as a ‘medical’ patient by paying physicians and/or the state for some kind of get-out-of-jail-free card.”

In the wake of these words, Edson, his wife Georgia and Mile High NORML director Scott Greene have resigned from the organization. But while the post makes it seem as if St. Pierre wrote an essay on the topic with the intention of widely disseminating his views, these remarks were never meant for public consumption. Instead, they were written as a note to James Clark, a California-based attorney who’s part of a LISTSERV for the NORML legal committee — an electronic mailing list whose members include approximately 450 lawyers across the country.

After receiving the material from Edson, Bloom says he got in touch with St. Pierre to make sure the comments were genuine, and gave St. Pierre the opportunity to edit them.

“I wrote back and said, ‘I don’t want to edit something people have seen. It would make it look like I was changing what I said,’” St. Pierre recalls.

Nonetheless, some edits were made — but by Bloom, not St. Pierre. Bloom took out small portions that specifically referred to Clark, including this line: “James, you can certainly choose to defend a system that benefits those who are largely gaming the system.” The original document is also on view below, providing the opportunity to compare and contrast.

“I also said I’d rather [Bloom] not publish it, because it was an internal discussion — just a dashed-off note,” St. Pierre continues. “And he said, ‘I think I’m going to publish it as is.’ And I said, ‘I hope you put it in the proper context.’ But then it gets published, and it has my name on it and the note, and that’s all. So a reader would probably think I was trying to be unnecessarily provocative.”

Here is the LISTSERVE piece in its entirety.  I’ve used strikeout to indicate the portions that Bloom removed and boldface to indicate the additions Bloom made… you can decide if the edits changed the tone of this private email response on a specific topic to a specific lawyer:

Allen St. Pierre on Medical Marijuana

Hello James,

Kicking my friends or encouraging them to please wake up from their hazy field of dreams?

Defending the ‘medical’ cannabis industry is so yesterday (unless you’ve been hired to legally defend a dispensary or to establish one…). Why not acknowledge the political and legal farce it is and focus on the REALreal problem at hand…: ending Cannabis Prohibition?

The law and court precedents are fairly clear here.…Self-preservation (yes)…., large scale cultivation and sales (no).

It is just this simple.

The numerous actions by the feds and state govts in the last two weeks make this abundantly clear:

*ATF memo (no Second Amendment rights for patients)
*Feds crack down on banks doing business with CBCs (cannabis buyer’s clubs)
*Feds send forfeiture notice to CBC landlords
*Feds send warnings to local CBCs that they must move or shut because they’re within 1,000 of federally subsidized school
*IRS 280E decision against HHC (can the current retail industry survive this blow?)
*Feds send shut down notices to 25% of the CBCs in San Diego

And what MOREmore re-assertion of primacy will we get today from the feds?

If this were the 1920s, your advocacy of thetoday’s ‘medical’ cannabis industry of today would sound like a lawyer back then fronting for the legal sellers of ‘prescription’ alcohol during Alcohol Prohibition.(whoThe med-pot industry, of course, opposedopposes actual legalization…just likesuch as last year’s Prop 19, which was also opposed by the pot prohibition profiteering communities in the state’s northern ‘grow’ counties).

Prescriptive alcohol was a sham then, the ‘medical’ cannabis industry (not medical cannabis itself) is largely a sham now.

Is this news? NORML, and lawyers like Bill Panzer, have been warning ganjapreneurs and their legal counsel at our seminars and conferences about this political and legal box canyon since at least 2002.

Cannabis consumers, who NORML represents, want good, affordable cannabis products without having to go through the insult and expense of having to ‘qualify’qualifying as a ‘medical’ patient by paying physicians and/or the state for some kind of ‘get out of jail free’ card.

How intellectually honest is all of this?

James, you can certainly choose to defend a system that benefits those who are largely gaming the system, however, NORML prefers to take a more honest and transparent approach that advocates that cannabis should be legal for all adult consumers, including healthy ones.

;D)

KIND regards,

– Allen
NORML

Allen St. Pierre is the executive director of NORML

So what you have here is Allen writing a response on a private LISTSERVE to a lawyer who questioned Allen’s posting of an op-ed by a California cop that described medical marijuana in California as a farce and a sham.  Then another lawyer in Colorado who defends the medmj industry took offense, feeling Allen was demeaning his clients.  This is back in October.  Then that Colorado lawyer takes the text off the private LISTSERVE and begins distributing it to as many people as he can as part of his own agenda to discredit Allen.  Steve Bloom finally takes takes the bait this month and splashes the edited, out-of-context email all over his website as if it were a public pronouncement from NORML, leading to re-posts on other cannabis websites and countless angry denunciations and spirited defenses in the comments sections.

These actions were taken by people who considered themselves proponents of legalization and big supporters of NORML.  Gosh, with friends like these…

Download Link: Secret Stash - Register to access
Standard Podcast Feed (27.5MB 64Kbps) | High-Def Podcast Feed (82.5MB 192Kbps)
Download audio file (NORML_SHOW_LIVE_2012-01-06.mp3)

Hemp Headlines

Brought to you by Cannabis Fantastic

1. Detroit teen used by cops for drug sting found murdered, mutilated, and set on fire
2. Federal Judge Tosses Governor Brewer’s Case over Medical Marijuana
3. The Republican Candidates Address Marijuana and Hemp in NH
4. Second Marijuana Related Initiative May be Headed for the Ballot
5. Australians Consume the Most Marijuana Globally

Daily Toker Tunes

Rockin’ Friday: Brought to you by Urb Thrasher from Urb Age Designs

• MonstrO – Anchors Up!

CelebStoner.com Entertainment Report with Steve Bloom, co-author of Reefer Movie Madness: The Ultimate Stoner Film Guide

• Steve Bloom explains his decision to post Allen St. Pierre’s private “farce” remarks on CelebStoner.com

This Month in NORML with Executive Director Allen St. Pierre

• Allen St. Pierre addresses the controversy over his “farce” remarks on CelebStoner.com

Before we get started, let me make clear that this list is not “The Best People” or “The Worst People” or “The Most Important People”.  It is also not NORML’s official endorsement or condemnation of anyone listed.  This is merely my review of some of the personal stories in cannabis law reform, some whom you’ll recognize, others who appear briefly in a news report and are forgotten, that I felt needed recognition.  In fact, if you count them up, it’s more than ten people.

The Top Ten People in Marijuana in 2011 (audio mp3)

10. William Breathes – Journalism defeating unscientific and inaccurate DUID laws in Colorado

William Breathes, Denver WestWord's pot critic

When you say “medical marijuana” to most Americans, they will think “California”.  But Colorado has actually the most regulated and state-developed medical marijuana program in the country.  Per capita, Denver has far more medical marijuana dispensaries than Los Angeles or San Francisco/Oakland.  So I had no doubt that someone from Colorado would have to be included on this list.

Unfortunately, most of activism headlines out of Colorado in 2011 detailed the kind of immaturity and shenanigans that reflect poorly on marijuana activism.  2011 saw Miguel Lopez hectoring a legislator into dropping a patient privacy amendment, lecturing legislative committees, and accused of stealing and destroying legalization petitions.  Corey Donahue was jailed for disrupting a meeting organizing supporters of a legalization initiative, had his “Crazy for Justice” propose making April 20th a state holiday, and is accused of stealing documents from the state’s medical marijuana enforcement division (awaiting re-trial following mis-trial because Miguel Lopez was filming the jury selection).  Kathleen Chippi, Robert Chase, and Laura Kriho boasted openly about their active opposition to legalization efforts.

Thankfully, the “pot critic” of Denver’s alt-weekly, WestWord, comes to the rescue with an inspiring tale of one journalist’s use of the scientific method to help defeat bad anti-cannabis legislation.  Colorado had proposed a “5ng/mL per se DUID” standard, sort of the idea represented by a 0.08 blood-alcohol level to supposedly net drunk drivers.  The problem is that cannabis isn’t alcohol.  The science shows no reliable “impairment standard” for THC for every person.  Marijuana smokers can test above 5ng without displaying any impairment, and frequent consumers, like medical marijuana patients, can be way above 5ng with no recent consumption at all.

Breathes, a patient, took it upon himself to abstain from marijuana use for fifteen hours.  He was then tested and found to be at 13.5ng/mL, even as he was completely sober after a night of restful sleep.  This front-page news and subsequent support from new studies and a deadlocked task force of experts forced the Colorado legislators to kill the proposal.  Which, sadly, was then embraced by…

9. Alison Holcomb – New Approach Washington’s legalization adopts Colorado’s defeated DUID provision

Alison Holcomb of ACLU-WA

Washington State is poised in 2012 to have a marijuana legalization proposal on the ballot that stands a serious chance of winning.  Alison Holcomb, the Drug Policy Director at ACLU of Washington, has done a remarkable job lining up high-profile supporters, including travel guru Rick Steves, Seattle City Attorney Pete Holmes, former US Attorney John McKay, and former FBI Special Agent in Charge of Seattle Division, Charles Mandigo; as well as securing the big-dollar funding an initiative needs to be successful.

However, controversy within the Washington marijuana movement erupted as activists got wind of the details within I-502, the Holcomb-sponsored marijuana legalization initiative.  ACLU’s polling showed the two biggest obstacles to legalization support among the public are “What About the Children?!?” and “Beware the Stoned Drivers!!!”.  To assuage the public’s fear of stoned teenagers, I-502 sets a 21 age limit and zero tolerance for any use by drivers in that age group.  More controversially, to mitigate the stoned driver fear, I-502 adopts the same 5ng/mL per se DUID standard that had just been defeated in Colorado.

That DUID standard has caused longtime legalization advocates, including NORML attorney Douglas Hiatt, NORML Board Member Jeff Steinborn, and Seattle Hempfest Director Vivian McPeak, to publicly condemn I-502.  (To their credit, none of them have been arrested for stealing from and disrupting their opposition, a la Colorado above.)  It will be up to the voters in the Evergreen State to decide whether a few innocent tokers jailed on DUID is worth the potential of all tokers being innocent of possession.

8. Willie Nelson – the case of the living legend and the evaporating marijuana

How do you turn six ounces into three ounces into just a pot pipe? Ask Willie!

Bless Willie Nelson, he’s been a lifetime supporter of NORML and voices many pro-legalization ads on our radio show.  He’s always been synonymous with pot smoking.  But this year, he was one of the 850,000+ arrests for marijuana possession.  The case of Willie Nelson in Sierra Blanca, Texas, shone a spotlight on the idiocy of marijuana prohibition.  In its prosecution, it highlighted the disparity of the “justice” system when it comes to drugs and the rich and famous vs. the poor and anonymous.  The fallout has been a nascent political movement and another successful year of touring for the 78-year-old.

In late 2010, Willie was busted by Border Patrol when his tour bus passed through Sierra Blanca, Texas.  Cops seized six ounces of marijuana according to the reports.  In response, Willie notified Steve Bloom of CelebStoner that he was calling for a “Teapot Party” to promote the cause of legalization, which in 2011 gained mainstream political coverage for endorsing Republican Gary Johnson for president, before backpedaling to account for the singer’s support of Democrat Dennis Kucinich.

As Winter 2011 gave way to Spring, the six ounces of marijuana somehow became just three ounces of marijuana.  The county attorney joked, “Between me and the sheriff, we threw out enough of it or smoked enough so that there’s only three ounces, which is within my jurisdiction.”  But the traditional media didn’t get the joke when they reported Willie would be able to get out of jail time if he sang “Blue Eyes Cryin’ in the Rain” in court and pay a fine.  The judge confirmed the hoax and said Willie could just plead guilty by mail and pay a fine.

Also in the Spring of 2011, eleven hours’ drive across the state in Tyler, Texas, a jury sentenced Henry Walter Wooten to 35 years in prison (that’s 420 months; dig the irony) for the possession of four-and-a-half ounces of marijuana.  He did have two felony convictions from around two dozen years ago, one for having a gun without a permit and another for selling cocaine.  Most of all, he can’t sing “Blue Eyes Cryin’ in the Rain” worth a damn.

This summer, prosecutors agreed to let Willie plead guilty not to three ounces of marijuana but just possession of paraphernalia, which put him out $780 in fines and court costs.  In that deal, there was no punishment or acknowledgement of possession of any marijuana.  But so far the judge isn’t accepting that, saying the singer doesn’t deserve “special treatment”.

7. Patricia Spottedcrow – Single mother of four imprisoned a decade over $31 worth of pot

Patricia Spottedcrow got ten years for selling $31 worth of marijuana.

Every year there are busts of marijuana consumers that tug at the heart strings.  This year, the tale of Patricia Spottedcrow in Oklahoma garnered national attention:

(AOL News) Patricia Marilyn Spottedcrow, a 25-year-old mother of four, and her mother, Delita Starr, 50, sold an $11 dime bag to a police informant in Oklahoma on Dec. 31, 2009. The informant returned two weeks later to buy $20 of marijuana. Spottedcrow, who worked in nursing homes before her arrest, told The Oklahoman she did it to get some extra money.

The women were charged with drug distribution and possession of a dangerous substance in the presence of a minor, because Spottedcrow’s children were in the house during the transaction. They were offered plea deals of two years in prison but decided to enter a guilty plea instead, a gamble they took because neither had prior convictions and because the amount of drugs sold was so small.

The gamble did not pay off. Spottedcrow was given sentences of 10 years in prison for distribution and two years for possession, to run concurrently. When she was picked up to be taken to prison, she had marijuana in her jacket pocket, which led to another two-year concurrent sentence and a fine of nearly $1,300.

The judge in this story feels like she was compassionate in not sentencing the grandmother of Spottedcrow’s children, ages 9, 4, 3, and 1, to any jail time so she can raise the grandkids while mom is in prison.  Gee, thanks judge!  The family is so struggling to make ends meet they sell dime bags, so lets give grandma four mouths to feed all by herself.

But at least this high-level criminal mastermind is behind bars.  Oklahoma is safe now that $31 worth of weed was taken off the streets and an underpaid nursing home attendant is locked up.

6. Mackenzie Allen – Former cop’s legalization question tops Presidential survey

Continuing a theme he established even as a candidate, President Obama solicited the American people on their concerns on the most pressing issues facing America today.  In January, he utilized YouTube to have citizens ask video questions, to be voted on for response.  Mackenzie Allen, a retired law enforcement officer who represents LEAP (Law Enforcement Against Prohibition) asked the top rated question, which garnered 13,842 votes – over 1% of all votes cast (people could vote for more than one question).  Of the 193,060 people who voted more than 7% voted for the LEAP question.  That’s about one in fourteen people who took the time to Ask Obama.

Click here to view the embedded video.

As a police officer, I saw how waging the war on drugs has cost a trillion dollars and thousands of lives but does nothing to reduce drug use. Should we discuss legalizing marijuana and other drugs, which would eliminate the violent criminal market?

As an honorable mention, our own Erik Altieri in September penned NORML’s legalization question which garnered the most votes in the “We the People” survey.  This latest incarnation of “Change.gov” / “Open for Questions” / “Citizen’s Briefing Book” / “Ideas for Change” / “Ask Obama” marked the ninth time the president has asked and the ninth time the American people have screamed, overwhelmingly, “legalize it!”

Click here to view the embedded video.

5. U.S. Attorney Laura E. Duffy – One of four engaged in “crack down” on California medical marijuana

Laura E. Duffy, US Attorney for Southern District of California

The four US Attorneys in California, apparently acting without direction from President Obama or Attorney General Holder, moved to crack down on what they consider to be “abuses” of medical marijuana laws of California.  Referring to Proposition 215, the 1996 initiative that excepted medical use of marijuana from criminal prosecution, Andre Birotte Jr., U.S. attorney for California’s central district, said “What we’ve seen, unfortunately, is the Compassionate Use Act has really turned into the Commercial Use Act.”  (It remains unclear to me why federal US Attorneys think they have standing to evaluate what is and isn’t an abuse of state law, but I’m one of those weirdos who’s read the 9th and 10th Amendments to the Constitution.)

But I’ve singled out Laura E. Duffy of the four because she went above and beyond her colleagues in not only ignoring her boss’s previous policy statements and the 9th & 10th Amendments, but in also threatening the 1st Amendment over medical marijuana:

(California Watch) Federal prosecutors are preparing to target newspapers, radio stations and other media outlets that advertise medical marijuana dispensaries in California, another escalation in the Obama administration’s newly invigorated war against the state’s pot industry.

U.S. Attorney Laura E. Duffy, whose district includes Imperial and San Diego counties, said marijuana advertising is the next area she’s “going to be moving onto as part of the enforcement efforts in Southern California.” Duffy said she could not speak for the three other U.S. attorneys covering the state but noted their efforts have been coordinated so far.

“I’m not just seeing print advertising,” Duffy said in an interview with California Watch and KQED. “I’m actually hearing radio and seeing TV advertising. It’s gone mainstream. Not only is it inappropriate – one has to wonder what kind of message we’re sending to our children – it’s against the law.”

4. Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer – loves fed marijuana policy, hates fed immigration policy

To be fair, this ability is not uncommon among politicians.

There was no shortage of state governors I could have chosen for this spot.  New Jersey’s reprehensible Chris Christie has stonewalled every step of the way in implementing The (No) Garden State’s medical marijuana law, even trying to turn the mandated six dispensaries into only four, limited to growing but three strains statewide that measure less than 10% THC.  Montana’s quirky Brian Schweitzer won praise for vetoing an attempt to repeal medical marijuana, only to earn scorn for allowing “Repeal Lite” to pass without his signature.  Washington’s spineless Chris Gregoire line-item vetoed a legislative measure to establish regulated medical marijuana dispensaries on the pretense of protecting state workers, as did Rhode Island’s invertebrate Lincoln Chafee, when the feds sent a threatening letter.  But then Gregoire and Chafee petitioned the feds to reschedule cannabis so they could operate their dispensaries.  Maryland’s sensible Martin O’Malley signed an expansion of affirmative defense and Delaware’s compassionate Jack Markell signed his state into becoming the 16th medical marijuana state.  Meanwhile, Oklahoma’s vile Mary Fallin signed a law that could mean a life sentence for making pot brownies, but Connecticut’s reasonable Dan Malloy made his state the 14th to decriminalize personal possession by adults.

However, for sheer boldfaced unadulterated political hypocrisy, I have to recognize Arizona’s two-faced Governor Jan Brewer.  First she campaigned against Prop 203 but later said she “believed in the will of the people” who passed that medical marijuana initiative.  Then she was lecturing police that they didn’t do enough to campaign against Prop 203 while admitting that she was “too busy” to do more herself.  Then she was stonewalling on the issuance of dispensary permits that the “will of the people” approved, because she was suing to see that the “will of the people” be denied by a federal court.

In other words, if the people of Arizona pass a law to get illegal marijuana to Arizonans, because Washington DC is out of touch, then the “will of the people” be damned.  Gov. Brewer will sue in federal court to uphold federal law.  But if the people of Arizona pass a law to get illegal Mexicans out of Arizona, because Washington DC is out of touch, then the “will of the people” is sacred.  Gov. Brewer will sue in federal court to uphold state law.  (I have no word on the governor’s position on illegal Mexican immigrants who need medical marijuana, but I’ll bet it is confusing.)

3. Former New Mexico Gov. Gary Johnson – former Republican, now Libertarian presidential candidate

Former NM Gov. Gary Johnson with me (in low light)

On the other end of the governor spectrum we find former New Mexico Gov. Gary Johnson.  The two-term Republican governor had been touting his “Our America Initiative” in 2010 and appearing at NORML Conference and other pro-marijuana festivals in full-throated support of legalization of marijuana for adult use.  His vocal support only grew in April 2011 as he announced his run as a Republican for the presidential nomination of the party, and not only continued to appear at pro-legalization rallies, and even had Willie Nelson’s Teapot Party (briefly) endorse his presidential run.

Alas, the Republican party and traditional media didn’t agree and denied Johnson all but a couple of chances on the national debate stage to state his case.  The marijuana issue was ignored despite strong public inquiry about it, even among Republicans.  Johnson continued to speak out on the issue to those who would listen.  But this week, he has abandoned his bid for the Republican nomination and taken up a presidential campaign for the Libertarian ticket.

To his credit, Rep. Ron Paul remains in the race for the Republican nomination and even comes in 2nd in the current polling in advance of next Tuesday’s Iowa caucus.  Paul, a longtime supporter of NORML’s mission, has also introduced The Industrial Hemp Farming Act of 2011 and been a co-sponsor of other pro-marijuana federal legislation.  But the last time Rep. Paul spoke directly to an audience of marijuana activists was 1988.

2. Rep. Barney Frank – the lion of legalization retires from Congress

After sixteen terms in the US House of Representatives, liberal Congressman Barney Frank of Massachusetts is set to retire.  He’s sponsored or co-sponsored just about every pro-marijuana bill that has ever died in Congress.  He’s spoken directly to pro-marijuana audiences.  For me, though, my favorite Barney Frank moments are when he is chiding conservatives on their decidedly big-government, wasteful-spending, anti-states-rights support of marijuana prohibition:

Click here to view the embedded video.

1. Steven DeAngelo – Harborside’s CEO rebukes recreational legalization on Weed Wars

Harborside CEO Steven DeAngelo and me

Last year I was very encouraged by one Bay Area medical marijuana entrepreneur.  In 2010, Richard Lee put 1.5 million dollars of his own money to legalize marijuana for adult use, regardless of the reason why someone might choose to use it.  For months, I had predicted that the longer medical marijuana was an “industry”, the more that industry would fight to protect itself, even from legalization.

In 2011, I have been discouraged to have been proven right by another Bay Area medical marijuana entrepreneur, Steven DeAngelo of Harborside Health Center, the world’s largest marijuana dispensary.  In January, the IRS was auditing the books of Harborside, building a case that the dispensary was in violation of IRS Section 280E, which explicitly bans any tax deductions related to “trafficking in controlled substances.”  The pressure on DeAngelo wasn’t surprising.  ”If 280E is applied literally and strictly,” DeAngelo said, “it has the potential to close down Harborside and every other medical cannabis dispensary.”

In an effort apparently calculated to steer the IRS away from any claim that Harborside’s business might not be serving strictly medical needs, DeAngelo began casting aspersions on Richard Lee’s legalization effort, which he had publicly supported the year prior.  ”I warned people who were pushing Prop. 19 that losing elections would have consequences,” DeAngelo said, “In large part what we’re seeing is the consequences of an overreach by our community.”  DeAngelo published a manifesto entitled “At the Crossroads, or Wellness, Not Intoxication”, where he chides the legalization supporters fighting for a right to recreational cannabis use, saying, “very little cannabis use is actually for recreational purposes, or intoxication. This truth is not negated by the fact that many users of cannabis buy into the misconception that their own use is recreational.”

Steven and his brother Andrew DeAngelo then became the subjects of a Discovery Channel reality show called Weed Wars.  In the press tours promoting the show, both brothers clearly said “I don’t believe that any psychoactive substance should be used for recreation“ and “we do not support the legalization of cannabis for recreational purposes.”  Activists were outraged and what followed from Steven DeAngelo were semantic explanations and rhetorical absurdities.

This all culminated in the fourth installment of Weed Wars closing with Steven DeAngelo saying “I don’t believe in legalizing cannabis for recreational purposes; I think cannabis should be used for purposes of wellness.”  Again, activists were outraged, pointing out DeAngelo was a lifelong legalization activist.  DeAngelo responded again with more rhetoric about believing nobody should be subject to criminal penalties for marijuana and justifications about promoting “wellness” and dissing “recreation” being just a strategy for achieving legalization (which he’s told the public he’s against).  He even tries to shift the blame to editing at the Discovery Channel, when his appearances on live TV show that he meant exactly what he said after editing on Weed Wars.

Steven DeAngelo, CEO of Harborside Health Center and recently star of Discovery Channel’s Weed Wars, has come under fire for his comments at the conclusion of Episode 4 where he said, “I don’t believe in legalizing cannabis for recreational purposes; I think cannabis should be used for purposes of wellness.”  Steven took some heat in cyberspace, particularly Steve Bloom’s fiery denunciation in CelebStoner.com (“Say it ain’t so, Steve DeAngelo!”).

What is it with the weed guys and the funny hats?

DeAngelo has responded in CelebStoner with some backpedaling on the statement, claiming his naïveté in television by not realizing how editors would snip out his “comments denouncing all criminal penalties” and leave “no recreational legalization” hanging there out of context.  That could be the case, though the DeAngelo brothers have made the same “no recreational legalization” statements on live interviews on MSNBC (Dylan Ratigan) and FOX News (Bill O’Reilly)  leading up to the premiere of Weed Wars.  During the unedited 9:31 of the Ratigan segment and the unedited 5:17 of the O’Reilly segment, I didn’t hear any ”comments denouncing all criminal penalties”.  In fact, in the Ratigan segment I heard this exchange:

RATIGAN: So you think the recreational – the legalization of marijuana as a recreational drug is a very different debate than the use of marijuana as a medicine for specific treatment?

DeANGELOs: Absolutely.

RATIGAN: And your goal is to draw the distinction between those who are suffering in the prohibition of recreational use that is preventing them from gaining legitimate access to the medicinal use.

STEVEN DeANGELO: Yes, exactly.

RATIGAN: Do I have it?

ANDREW DeANGELO: We couldn’t have said it better ourselves.

That really doesn’t sound like “Everybody oughtta be able to use cannabis without criminal penalty; we just need to call it ‘wellness’ to get there.”  That sounds like you see two types of users, “medical” and “recreational”, and the latter are de-legitimized by the former.  I also heard Andrew toss off a line about medical marijuana patients being “the last people in the world who would probably buy a gun”.  Huh?  WTF?  And Steven said “In California, 67% of the people voted in favor of Prop 215″.  It was actually 55.58%.  But they hadn’t seen the final Weed Wars episodes at that time, so they wouldn’t have known they needed to play up the “comments denouncing all criminal penalties” angle, right?

So forgive me if I’m not convinced by this latest round of trying to play “hate the stoners” for the Discovery crowd and “don’t arrest stoners” for the CelebStoner crowd.  And I will not accept hints that this criticism is the sowing of “disunity” when he’s the one distancing himself from legalization for all purposes.  Every “legalizer” I know of votes for every medical initiative, but Prop 19 showed us the reverse is not true.  Who’s the disunited, the “legalizers” trying to protect us all, or the “medicalizers” who keep fighting for that subgroup of us who are sick or disabled?  Even championing an idea that all adults should use it for “wellness” separates those of us who are clearly not well from our cannabis use.  Some people will have an unhealthy relationship with cannabis.  They should be just as legal as alcoholics and chain smokers.

Let me conclude by once again addressing Seven DeAngelo’s latest defense of his central “all use is wellness” platform in the CelebStoner response:

At the same time, it’s my strong belief that our movement’s use of the concept and terminology of “legalization for recreational purposes” has caused us tremendous damage. Our opponents have used the term to paint us as unrestrained hedonists who advocate a society-wide lifestyle of self-indulgence. In the ’80s, this kind of propaganda succeeded in undoing all the accomplishments our movement had made up till then – and kept us on the defense until medical cannabis reinvigorated the movement in the mid-’90s. But the anti-recreational propaganda left a bitter legacy of workplace urinalysis, housing discrimination, transplant denials, student-aid denials, interference with parent’s custodial rights and more horrors sadly still with us.

There was a time, before our discoveries of industrial hemp and medical cannabis, when an individual-rights argument was the main tool in the activist toolkit. Today, we have more compelling and effective reasons to advance for changing the laws than an individual’s right to get high. The discovery of the endo-cannabinoid system has established a sound scientific basis for the incredibly widespread therapeutic efficacy of cannabis, and almost two decades of experience has taught us that the vast majority of cannabis consumers are using it for wellness purposes. In addition, dozens of public opinion polls have shown that Americans support medical cannabis in numbers far greater than “recreational” cannabis.

For me, all of this points us in the direction of emphasizing the use of cannabis for wellness purposes, rather than for “recreational” purposes. That’s why I’ve said I don’t believe in legalizing cannabis for recreational purposes – and still believe that. But I do believe adult Americans should be empowered to make their own health and wellness decisions about cannabis. Several months ago I released a paper, “Wellness Not Intoxication,” in which I called on the movement to reevaluate its use of the recreational-cannabis concept.

Steve, I appreciate your elaboration, but you’re still hitching your legalization wagon to the “it’s OK to smoke pot because…” theory, and as long as you do that, you invite some authority to determine whether your “because” is valid enough to keep you out of jail.

You base your pivot on “recreational” on a faulty analysis of the pendulum swing in public opinion from pro-legalization 1970-1979 to anti-legalization 1980-1989 as being one where our opponents painted us as “unrestrained hedonists who advocate a society-wide lifestyle of self-indulgence”.  But that hedonism image wasn’t built on just marijuana; it was also built on rampant cocaine use, swingers and orgies, and Studio 54 tales of excess.

Ronald Reagan successfully painted the image of “Morning in America” by coupling the inflation, unemployment, crime stats, and general “malaise” of the post-Nixon years to the ideals and culture of the 60′s-70′s hippie movement.  The biggest symbol of that was the pot leaf.  And as Richard Pryor, John Belushi, and Len Bias lent celebrity status to the tragedy of cocaine abuse and as “Miami Vice” showed cocaine to be the devil’s plaything, then the popularity of that marijuana which had been so tightly interwoven with cocaine as just a good-time party drug (see: HIGH TIMES centerfolds circa 1978-1982) began to wane.

You are right that in the 1990′s, medical marijuana revitalized legalization’s popularity, primarily by re-framing it as a medicine with benefits for very sick people.  Add to that Baby Boomers whose kids flew the nest and who now return to the pot they remembered in the 60′s-70′s and you have a new public mindset that understands that marijuana is not cocaine and is not one of the harmful drugs out there.  They even understand that it is safer than alcohol!

No matter how much pot helps the guy in the wheelchair, there are still guys like me who smoke pot because it is enjoyable.  It may indeed be staving off my alcoholism, my depression, my insomnia, but those are secondary benefits to the primary reason I use cannabis, which is “when I smoke it it makes me feel good”.  Just like my eating an orange because it tastes good, even though it is providing fiber for healthy digestion and vitamin C to stave off rickets.  You want to call that “wellness”, but that invites the listener to call a shot of whiskey, a good cigar, a glass of grapefruit juice, and a session of sex (self or shared) “wellness” and that’s where loss of credibility will overtake your re-framing.

It’s now the 2010′s; we have older adults with personal experience, middle-aged adults who’ve seen it as medicine, and younger adults who’ve grown up in a world were medical use is OK and Google tells them all the facts about cannabis that you and I growing up could never have learned (save reading “Emperor” or Dr. Tod’s papers, not exactly available in a high school library where I matriculated).  As I’ve shown with polls and election results, the 1990′s strategy of “medicalization” is backsliding and the 1970′s strategy of “legalization” is on the rise.

Calling it “wellness” (or “sacrament”, for that matter) won’t alleviate the fears parents have that their kids will come home stinking of “wellness” or you might be so “extra-well” that you cross the center line on the highway.

Finally, while in your personal opinion I should (if possible) consult with a doctor before using cannabis, in my personal opinion, I don’t need the permission of a king, court, congress, cleric, or clinician to use cannabis.  I need only the same permission a beer drinker or cigarette smoker needs: an ID that proves I’m an adult.

Download Link: Secret Stash - Register to access
Standard Podcast Feed (27.5MB 64Kbps) | High-Def Podcast Feed (82.5MB 192Kbps)
Download audio file (NORML_SHOW_LIVE_2011-11-18.mp3)

Hemp Headlines

Brought to you by Cannabis Fantastic

1. CBS Poll shows majority believe medical marijuana isn’t being used only to alleviate suffering among the sick and dying
2. Copenhagen, Denmark, votes to legalize marijuana
3. NE 420 license plate denied for Nebraska lawyer
4. Washington cops organization unanimously rejects I-502
5. $3 pot bust leads to felony charges for Lake County teen

Daily Toker Tunes

Rockin’ Friday: Brought to you by Urb Thrasher from Urb Age Designs

• Greensky Bluegrass – “Don’t Lie”

CelebStoner.com Entertainment Report with Steve Bloom, co-author of Reefer Movie Madness: The Ultimate Stoner Film Guide

• First-hand accounts of the Occupy Wall Street protests this week

Video streaming by Ustream
Download Link: Secret Stash - Register to access
Standard Podcast Feed (27.5MB 64Kbps) | High-Def Podcast Feed (82.5MB 192Kbps)
Download audio file (NORML_SHOW_LIVE_2011-11-04.mp3)

Hemp Headlines

Brought to you by Cannabis Fantastic

1. Bonnie Dumanis changes her stripes, claims she supports medical marijuana as she runs for San Diego mayor
2. Drug Reform Conference in Los Angeles features speech by presidential candidate Gov. Gary Johnson
3. San Jose mayor proposing new taxes to cover cost of referendum
4. Montana poll shows majority support for new medical marijuana restrictions

Daily Toker Tunes

Rockin’ Friday: Brought to you by Urb Thrasher from Urb Age Designs

• Kyng – “Trampled Sun”

CelebStoner.com Entertainment Report with Steve Bloom, co-author of Reefer Movie Madness: The Ultimate Stoner Film Guide

• New Harold & Kumar 3D Christmas movie review

Radical Rant

• Medical marijuana turns 15 years old tomorrow – has it reached its zenith?

Video streaming by Ustream
Download Link: Secret Stash - Register to access
Standard Podcast Feed (27.5MB 64Kbps) | High-Def Podcast Feed (82.5MB 192Kbps)
Download audio file (NORML_SHOW_LIVE_2011-10-21.mp3)

Hemp Headlines

Brought to you by Cannabis Fantastic

1. GOP Candidates on Marijuana Issues
2. Lake Forest closes dispensaries in wake of federal threats
3. Twin Falls, Idaho police surprised by record-low marijuana seizures in county
4. Major bust in Miami nets zero arrests

Daily Toker Tunes

Rockin’ Friday: Brought to you by Urb Thrasher from Urb Age Designs

• Across the Sun – “Tipping the Scales”

CelebStoner.com Entertainment Report with Steve Bloom, co-author of Reefer Movie Madness: The Ultimate Stoner Film Guide

Radical Rant

• There is no medical marijuana, no industrial hemp, no ganja sacrament, and no recreational pot. These is one plant – cannabis – and we must rally together to end its prohibition.

Download Link: Secret Stash - Register to access
Download audio file (NORML_SHOW_LIVE_2011-10-07.mp3)

Hemp Headlines

Brought to you by Cannabis Fantastic

1. Congress considering new law that would criminalize conspiracy to break US drug laws in foreign countries, even if not illegal in those countries
2. Holland to require all cannabis at greater than 15% THC to be classified as a “hard drug
3. US Attorneys announce new crackdown on medical marijuana commerce

Daily Toker Tunes

Brought to you by Urb Thrasher from Urb Age Designs

• Rockin’ Friday: Lacero – “Justless”

CelebStoner.com Entertainment Report with Steve Bloom, co-author of Reefer Movie Madness: The Ultimate Stoner Film Guide

• Did cannabis prohibition kill Steve Jobs?
• Latest Sports Cannabis Busts
• Tales from Occupy Wall Street

Grassroots Activism

• Karli Duran from San Antonio NORML with update on the 420 Smart Car

Download Link: Secret Stash - Register to access
Download audio file (NORML_SHOW_LIVE_2011-09-16.mp3)
Download Link: Secret Stash - Register to access
Download audio file (NORML_SHOW_LIVE_2011-09-16a.mp3)


Video streaming by Ustream

Radical Rant

Daily Toker Tunes

Brought to you by Urb Thrasher from Urb Age Designs

• Electric Tuesday: Melodramus – “Generation Same”

CelebStoner.com Entertainment Report with Steve Bloom, co-author of Reefer Movie Madness: The Ultimate Stoner Film Guide

• 22nd Annual Boston Freedom Rally takes place this Saturday
• Sarah Palin did cocaine and Michigan “Fab Five” basketball star Glenn Rice, according to new book
• HIGH TIMES loses to Wall St. Journal in NYMSL Championship

Patient Perspectives

• Federal medical marijuana patient Elvy Musikka discusses being harassed by Oregon State Police
• Mike Mullins and Jennifer Valley from Stoney Girl Gardens
• Joey Nieves from Ontario, Oregon’s 45th Parallel patient co-op

Video streaming by Ustream
Download Link: Secret Stash - Register to access
Download audio file (NORML_SHOW_LIVE_2011-09-02.mp3)

Hemp Headlines

Brought to you by Cannabis Fantastic

1. New SB423 restrictions on probationers and medical marijuana leaves Montana woman in intractable pain
2. International Cannabis & Hemp Expo moves out of Cow Palace to downtown Oakland in Oaksterdam
3. Colorado DUID panel cannot determine a per se limit of THC in blood to reliably indicate impairment
4. Massachusetts company completes sequencing of cannabis genome

Daily Toker Tunes

Brought to you by Urb Thrasher from Urb Age Designs

• Rockin’ Friday: Cannabis Corpse – “Beneath Grow Lights Thou Shalt Rise”

CelebStoner.com Entertainment Report with Steve Bloom, co-author of Reefer Movie Madness: The Ultimate Stoner Film Guide

• INTCHE moves to Oaksterdam
• HIGH TIMES outlast Wall St. Journal in 11-inning softball final, finishes season #1 at 9-1
• Stoner Movie Review: “Our Idiot Brother” with Paul Rudd
• Sebastian Bach’s home destroyed by East Coast flooding

Radical Rant

Video streaming by Ustream